Monoprice MBS-650 (8250) vs. Dayton Audio B652'Ōlelo'Ōlelo

No nā makahiki, ua halaʻole ka Dayton Audio B652 no ke poʻo inoa o "ka pelekane kaena kaulana loa o ka honua" -ʻo ia wale nō ka mea'ōlelo kūʻokoʻa pihaʻole e hiki iāʻoe ke kū pololei e hoʻolohe. Akā, ua hōʻea mai kahi paio hou a me ka mea maʻalahi i ka hoʻoukaʻana:ʻo ka Monoprice MBS-650 (ke kūʻai aku nei ka hui i lalo o ka huahana ID 8250).

01 o 06

ʻO ke kaʻina o ka make make

ʻO ka hōʻike MBOP-650 (8250) hōʻikeʻia me kaʻole a me nā kiʻiʻole. Brent Butterworth

Ma luna o kaʻilikai, ua nānā like nā pūʻulu leoʻelua o nā mea kani. He 6.5-iniʻi ka polypropylene-cone woofer, kahi liʻiliʻi liʻiliʻi (5/8-ini i ka Dayton, 1/2-inihi i ka Monoprice), a me kahi pāpaleʻeleʻeleʻeleʻele, i hoʻopaʻaʻia e vinyl e pili ana i 1 kapuaʻi kiʻekiʻe. Loaʻa iā lāua i ke kaʻina o ke kaʻina ala hiki ke kaʻawale - hoʻokahi wale no ka mana hana i ka papahana e mālama ai i ka puhiʻana (ke kuʻina i hōʻikeʻia ma ke kiʻi hope o kēiaʻatikala).

Aia kekahi mauʻokoʻa, akā. Hoʻomumuʻia ka pahu o Dayton i ke alumini,ʻoiai keʻano o ka monoprice o polypropylene. ʻO ka mua i kauʻia ka hoʻolālā pahuhopu, akāʻo ka hopena e pili ana i kahiʻaoʻao hope.

I kekahi,ʻo ka hakakā no "ka mea kamaʻilio punahele kiʻekiʻe" e like me keʻano o nā manu puaʻaʻelua e hakakā ana ma luna o ka make o armadillo heʻekahi. Eia kekahi, ponoʻoe i kahi'ōlelo kākā'ōlelo i kekahi lā. A inā heʻoluʻolu wikiōʻoe, e koi mau anaʻoe i ka mea kūkākūkā no kāu kālā me ka nuiʻole o ka nui āu e hoʻolālā ai i ka hoʻolimalimaʻana.

02 o 06

Nā Kūlana a me ka Hoʻonohonoho

ʻO kaʻaoʻao'ākau o ka pūnaewele waha punahele MBS-650 (8250). Brent Butterworth

• 6.5-iniha poly cone woofer
• 0.5-inihi poly dome tweeter
• Nā pelekikena laikini kelehe kala puna
• Nānā 11.9 x 8.1 x 6.4 i / 302 x 206 x 163 mm (hwd)
• Kaumaha 7.2 lbs./3.6 kg

ʻAʻole nui ka nui o ka hauʻoli e pili ana maʻaneʻi,ʻoiai he Monoprice MSB-650 wale nō he mea heluhelu'ōlelo puke maikaʻi. ʻOiaiʻo ka MBS-650 he kī liʻiliʻi o ka puʻuhole ma ke kua i ka mea e hiki ai iā ia ke kau i kahi pā, ke'ōlelo aku nei mākouʻaʻole mākou e hoʻohana. Ma ka hanaʻana pēlā e kāpae ai i kaʻaoʻao hope a hoʻololi i ka leo o ka mea'ōlelo. Akā, no ka noʻonoʻoʻana i ka mea kūʻaiʻole o kēia mea'ōlelo, hiki iā ia ke kūpono i keʻano kūpono. No laila inā ponoʻoe, e hiki iāʻoe ke hele i mua a kāpae i ke awa.

Hoʻomakaʻia ka ho'āʻoʻana ma ka haʻiʻana i nā mea kani leo MBS-650 me nā hola heʻono. A laila, ua hoʻokumuʻia kēlā me kēia MBS-650 ma luna o ka 28-ki luna-kiʻekiʻe, kahi kūkā o ka mea hoʻokūkū hoʻokūkū piha - piha ka maikaʻiʻoi aku ma mua o ka loaʻa pinepineʻana, ua maopopo iā mākou - a pili i kahi mea helu Denon A / V. Uaʻike mākou i kēia manawa e kani pono nā mea kelepona me nā kiʻi (hiki i nā pahu ke hoʻonani i ke ala o keʻano), no laila ua haʻalele mākou i kēlā ala no ke koena o ka hoʻokolohuaʻana.

ʻO ka mea e mahalo ai,ʻo ka Monoprice MBS-650 ke nānā maikaʻi aku i kona mele ma waho aʻe o ka Dayton Audio B652. ʻO ka mua he'ōwili palahiki i hoʻopuniʻia a puni kona woofer, i ka wā i hoʻokomoʻia ka woo o ka hope o ka wili i kahi kapi.

03 o 06

Wahi

Kōnae Kekona Biodine Audioton (Audio) Bature (5) a me Monoprice MBS-650 kelepona ('ākau). Brent Butterworth

Hoʻopuka mākou i ka hoʻonaniʻana o ka Monoprice MBS-650 maʻamau; e pono mākou e hoʻonohonoho i kekahi mau kaikamāhine e nānā i ka The Double on Amazon Instant Video , aʻo ka Monoprices ua'āpono pono.

ʻAʻoleʻo mākou i pili nui i ka loiloiʻana i ka mea'ōlelo i kēlā pō, akā uaʻike mākou i ka maʻalahi o ka leʻaleʻa i ke kani a komo i ka kiʻiʻoniʻoni me ka hoʻonāukiukiʻoleʻia e ka hōʻike MBS-650. Ua maikaʻi loa ka leo o ka leo, me kaʻike waleʻia o ka'ōpala he "boxy" keʻano o ke kani - ua kani ka leo e kani nei i ka waha o ka mea e kamaʻilio nei, akā he mau momona maʻamau i loko.

Ua lohe mākou i keʻano o ke kalaʻoniʻoni i ka wā e hula aiʻo Holly Cole i ka "Train Song," mai ko mākou mau hilinaʻi hila punahele 10 . Akāʻo ka mea nui, he maikaʻi loa ke kani no $ 30 wale nō - ma ka maikaʻi loa e like me ka mea i loheʻia e kekahi o nā mea i hoʻokomoʻia i loko o nā'ōnaehana hoʻohālikelike-i loko o ka pahu. ʻO ka leo o Cole he leo maikaʻi loa ia, me kahi hapa liʻiliʻi o ka momona ma ka piko waena / haʻahaʻa haʻahaʻa o kona leo (e pili ana i 2 kHz a pēlā). ʻO nā haʻahaʻa haʻahaʻa hohonu e hoʻomaka ana i ke kani e kani leo kūpono a me nā meaʻole . ʻAʻole kūpaʻa nui, aʻaʻole ikaika loa i nā haʻahaʻa haʻahaʻa, akā, he mau lōʻihi mai ke kāhili a weheʻoleʻia. He mea kupaianaha ke kiʻiʻoniʻoni no ke kumukūʻai. Ua hiki iā mākou ke hoʻomaopopo pono i kēlā me kēia mekino kani percussion i kahi mokulele ma waena o nā mea'ōlelo.

Ua hopohopo mākou i ka loheʻana i ka hoʻopaʻaʻana i ka "Shower the People" mai i Live at the Beacon Theatre - kekahi o nā hopena hoʻokani paʻakikī paʻakiki a mākou iʻike ai - ua kani maikaʻi loa, me kaʻikeʻoleʻia o ka pāʻana i ka leo o Taylor . He pāʻani wale nō ka piliʻole, akā,ʻo ka nui o nā mea $ 1,000 / pai ke kani i kēia ala.

ʻO ke ala o ka Monoprice MBS-650 heʻano leo nui keʻano. Ma ka meleʻo Holly Cole, ua kīʻia nā haners / maracas e like me nā pahu poli i hoʻopihaʻia me BBs ma mua o nā mea maoli. ʻO nā'āpana luna kiʻekiʻeʻelua, mai ka 5 a 20 kHz, uaʻano liʻiliʻi paha ka mea, i hoʻemiʻia keʻano o ka ākea a me ka "ea."

I ka wā i hoʻomaka ai mākou me "Rosanna,"ʻo Toto, uaʻike mākou i ka MBS-650 i ke kaniʻana i kahi leo kani i ka wā e kani ai; ua hoʻomaka ka woofer e hoʻomaka e hōʻino i mua o ka hanaʻana o ka nalu. ʻOiai ua hāpaiʻia nā kīʻaha i ka nui i ka manawa i kaulia ai mākou i ka "Kickstart My Heart" a Mötley Crüe, ua hiki iā mākou ke loaʻa ka MBS-650 a hiki i 103 dBC i ka 1ʻakahi me ka hoʻokaʻawaleʻoleʻiaʻana o ka haʻina.

Noe pehea e hoohalike ai i MBS-650 i ka Audioton Audio B652? ʻO ka B652 he kani nui aʻoi aʻe. Akā, iā mākou, ua kani ke kani i ka ma waena o waena a me keʻano oʻoleʻa, me ka hāʻawiʻana i nā leo e likeʻole me ka'ōlelo. Aʻo ka Dayton Audio B652,ʻaʻole i maʻalahi ka hoʻoloheʻana.

04 o 06

Nā ana

ʻO ka hui pinepineʻana o ka mea heluhelu ma kahi pūnaewele Monoprice MBS-650 (8250). Brent Butterworth

ʻO ka heluhelu pinepine
ʻO kahi axis: ± 4.3 dB mai 106 Hz a 20 kHz
Ka helu: ± 3.7 dB mai 106 Hz i 20 kHz

ʻAʻohe pono
Ke emi liʻiliʻi 7.4 ohms / 350 Hz / -1 °, 9 ohms ka inoa

Ke kekona (2.83 kekona / 1 mika, anechoic)
87.7 dB

Ua ana mākou i ka pane kelepona o ka MBS-650 ma ke hoʻohanaʻana i kahi kiʻina kūʻokoʻa, me ka mea'ōlelo ma kahi o 2 meter-kiʻekiʻe kiʻekiʻe a me ka leo kani ma 1 mika mai ka hoʻohanaʻana i kaʻoihana paʻakikī ma kahi o analyiser audio audio Clio 10 FW. nā hopena maikaʻi o nā mea e pili ana. Ua anaʻia ka pane ma muli o kahi kokoke i ka woofer a me ka port, e hōʻailona ana i ka pane o ka port a hōʻuluʻuluʻia me ka pane o ka woofer, a laila e hoʻopiliʻana i ka hopena i nā pale hana'ekepeke i 215 Hz. ʻO ka hiʻohiʻula polū ma ka pakuhi ma luna nei hōʻike i ka pane pinepine i ka axis; ke'ōmaʻomaʻo'ōmaʻomaʻo e hōʻike i ka awelika o nā pane ma 0, ± 15, a me ± 30'ūkelina i ka pae. Ua hoʻonāʻia nā hopena i ka 1/12 o ka octave.

ʻO kēia no kahi o ka paneʻana o ke alapine ka laulā no kēlā mea kamaʻilio maʻalahi,ʻo ka mea hoʻokahi wale nō me ka mana hoʻokahi e like me ke kuʻina. ʻO ke kau waena he lūlū wale nō koe no ka'ōloheloheʻoluʻolu, i hoʻonuiʻia ma ka 1.3 kHz, a he piʻi iki ma ka ike ma waena o 3.5 a 7.5 kHz -ʻo ia ka kumu o kaʻeleʻele i loheʻia kekahi manawa ma nā leo. He maikaʻi loa ka paneʻana o kahi axis, me ka'ōwili wikiwiki o ka ikaika ke neʻeʻoe i 30'eneke-axis.

Ua laweʻia kēia mahele me kaʻole o ka grille. ʻO ka grille he hopena iki wale nō ia, ke emi nui ka hoʻoukaʻana ma waena o 3 a me 5.5 kHz ma ka awelika o -2 dB.

ʻO ke kinoʻole a me kaʻike ke kiʻekiʻe, no laila, hiki i kekahi mīkini me 10 watts a iʻole paha ma kēlā me kēia pūnaewele ke hiki i kēia kelepona i nā kiʻekiʻe kiʻekiʻe me ka pilikiaʻole.

05 o 06

Nā Papa. Vs. Dayton B652

Monoprice MBS-650 (blue trace) vs. Dayton B652 (keʻokeʻo hōʻailona). Brent Butterworth

Eia ke ana āu i makemake ai eʻike:ʻo ka MBP-650 Monoprice (the blue trace) vs. ka Dayton Audio B652 (keʻokeʻoʻulaʻula), ua anaʻia i ka helu 0 ma ke axis. Eʻike i keʻano o ka nānāʻana o nā paneʻelua,ʻoiai ka pane a Monoprice he mea liʻiliʻi loa aʻo ka Dayton B652 he pane hohonu hohonu loa, me kahi helu -3 dB o 77 Hz vs. 106 Hz no ka Monoprice.

ʻOiaʻiʻo,ʻaʻole e nānā pono nā pane pane haʻahaʻa e like me ka mea i manaʻoʻia i ka pahu hoʻopaʻaʻo B652 a me ka pā o ka MBS-650. I kaʻikeʻana i kēia, ua nānā mākou i nā kikowaena ma Clio, a hoʻokau hou i nā ana kumu, a laila hoʻokūpaʻa iā lākou me nā anapili honua. Ua pololei nā mea a pau.

06 o 06

ʻO ka hopena hope

Hōʻike i ke kuʻina o ka Monoprice MBS-650. Brent Butterworth

No mākou, ua lanakila ka Monoprice no ka mea ua kani ka leo o ka haʻahaʻa. Hiki i kekahi ke makemake i ka Dayton B652 maikaʻi no kāna pane haʻahaʻa hohonu a me kahi kani maikaʻi. Akā ināʻoe eʻimi ana i kahi hoʻonani keiki - a iʻole ma kahi liʻiliʻi loa, e loaʻaʻoe i $ 30 -ʻo ka Monoprice MBS-650 eʻoi aku ka maikaʻi o kāu kālā.